The IBOC is like a power vampire, too. WOAI - about the last station I would think would shut it off - has been free of IBOC for at least a couple of months, and the signal is strong and almost like a local over Houston. Very from when they were running IBOC. The bandwidth is great, too, crystal clear audio. I know WBAP cared enough about their coverage to shut it off years ago. And they are pretty strong even in Houston, not as strong as WOAI, but listenable.
The thing about Chicago stations is that - I know a few decades ago they had listeners all over Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin. A source of news, information, and entertainment. Running IBOC probably abandons a lot of those folks because of the weakened signal. That is bound to translate into poorer building penetration in Chicago proper. I would think a prudent station would want as much power as they could get into buildings - shut off the blasted IBOC to get it.