I'll preface this by saying I'm in my upper 40s...
But I've always loved 80s pop/rock, even the rhythmic stuff. When the first all 80s formats started popping up around 2000, I couldn't get enough.
As pop started to crater in 1990 (in other words, when CHR either had to pick between going soft or going rhythmic) CHR kind of lost me. Yes, I liked some of the funky stuff, but there was a lot of terrible music out there. My favorite station growing up flipped to playing Fleetwood Mac and America. Its competition played a bunch of forgettable songs because they didn't want to be known as the "rap" station (primarily because the CHR in town that was very rhythmic had terrible billing.) I drifted to alternative for awhile; it was sonically closest to what I liked about 80s music and they played new wave for gold.
Then alternative kind of lost me as the 90s moved on. Nirvana and Pearl Jam were iconic. Papa Roach? Eh, I'll pass. The harder alternative got the less I listened to it. I've never fully come back to alternative radio.
The thing with the 90s is as more radio stations popped up as they were rim-shotted into the cities, you ended up with a bunch of stations chasing narrow niches and no real pop chart. There were two CHR charts. Two AC charts. Two rock charts.
The 90s mean so many different things to different people. Where do you find consensus, especially in years where mainstream CHR was effectively dead? I can turn on the 90s channel on XM now and not recognize songs that were big chart hits while I was in college, simply because the stations I listened to during those years were following a different chart. I know every song on the 80s channel because, even though every city had local hits, there was for the most of the decade only one Hot 100.
I suspect that a lot of the music that became modern AC will endure now that it's had a chance to rest a little. I can listen to Alanis again without cringing; the Lyft driver we had the other night punched out of her immediately because he's still burned on Hand In My Pocket. I'm intrigued by the new Pop Rocks channel on XM and find a lot of that stuff sounds pretty good up against Imagine Dragons. But radio leaned so hard on those titles for so long that they need a little rest before they sound fresh again.