You pooh-poohed the Takeis' internment with your "for a short time," as if they were in the camp overnight or for a few days rather than a year and a half, then you added "they all lived," again as if to tell Takei "So what's your complaint?" You dragged his "latent homosexuality" into the discussion as if he should have been eternally grateful just to have gotten into UCLA despite his hidden trait being offensive to "polite society." You bring up Pearl Harbor and -- correctly -- Japanese atrocities and say that Takei and his family wouldn't have been interned if the attack and atrocities hadn't happened. That MIGHT be borderline acceptable had Takei been a Japanese citizen or had been engaged in pro-Japan activities before Dec. 7, 1941. But Takei was 5 years old and just as American as you and me, and to suggest that he somehow deserved to be locked away, far from his California home, for "a short time" just because of his ethnicity is hideously wrong. You also called him a coward. I see no evidence of cowardice in Takei's not qualifying his criticisms of the American government's internment policy by mentioning how horrible Japan was, as if his not doing so somehow indicates he doesn't accept that fact. If you can cite statements by Takei that diminish the attack on Pearl Harbor and/or Japanese atrocities, please do so. Otherwise, if I may quote Joseph Welch, "Have you left no sense of decency?"I quite clearly said his rights were violated. I in no way "justified" what happened to the Japanese Americans and their internment in World War II, which I think most people agree was wrong, and definitely against the American Constitution, of which I am a proud supporter. What I did was contrast the treatment he received at the hands of the American government versus the treatment Americans received at the hand of the Japanese government.
It sure is strange how the same people who go to great lengths to let you know that they support Ukraine after the Russian invasion don't seem to understand their very own country was just as mercilessly attacked by the Japanese in 1941.
Let's be clear about this: Without the Japanese attack in Pear Harbor, there are no innocent civilians in Hawaii killed, there is no loss of life for thousands of US servicemen, there are no internment camps and there is no Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This is what happens when you start an unprovoked war.
George Takei is a coward who will never talk about those things. Furthermore, I have heard him talk about the internment camps many times, but never once about the blessings he received afterwards. America, like all other countries, has its faults and makes mistakes. In George's case, it did much to atone for them.
Last edited: