Macattack - good analysis; I thank you for the thought provoking post.
The only point on which I will disagree is Q101's ratings in the very early 00's. During that era, when the station had a nu metal and rap/rock lean - the numbers were actually darn good. They were cleaning up in young adults and also Men 25 to 54. At one point, the station cracked a 4 share in ages 12+. The instant Dave Richards left for Seattle and Tim Richards (inbound from Detroit CHR WKQI) took over and made the station more poppy, the numbers tanked and never recovered.
I honestly don't think Q101 would be that difficult to fix if the right person were leading the effort. I agree the nostalgia branding in & of itself will only take the station so far.
The only point on which I will disagree is Q101's ratings in the very early 00's. During that era, when the station had a nu metal and rap/rock lean - the numbers were actually darn good. They were cleaning up in young adults and also Men 25 to 54. At one point, the station cracked a 4 share in ages 12+. The instant Dave Richards left for Seattle and Tim Richards (inbound from Detroit CHR WKQI) took over and made the station more poppy, the numbers tanked and never recovered.
I honestly don't think Q101 would be that difficult to fix if the right person were leading the effort. I agree the nostalgia branding in & of itself will only take the station so far.