Hands down, Dial Global's "America's Best" is really the best of the bunch. The DJs are very good and the songs are well-chosen, adult music from the 50s to today. I worked at MOYL stations twice and the music mix was a) too old, b) not hit-oriented enough and c) inconsistant in that one quarter hour you might hear almost all pre-Beatles music and another quarter hour you might hear all post-Beatles music. I haven't heard Timeless Cool yet but I fear it violates Rule B: I don't think you can have a format aimed at older listeners with more than an occasional unfamiliar song.
When I read others on this thread saying "Oh, go ahead and program it yourself" I shuddered. I have heard MANY more poorly programmed local operations than well-done ones. I just can't see playing any song recorded before 1950. There just aren't enough people alive who want to hear a song that's more than 60 years old. I'm sorry but we really can't serve listeners over 75 because they're not reliably going to patronize your sponsors. (Yes, I know you have a 90 year old who shows up at all your live remotes but you can't build a radio station on that.) Most of your playlist should sound like what a Soft AC station sounded like 20 years ago: Kenny Rogers, Barry Manilow, Dionne Warwick, Carpenters, Beatles, Fifth Dimention, Sinatra, Streisand, Neil Diamond. As the Soft AC station in your town plays Pink and Daughtry to keep up with their demographic changes, you really can't play more than a couple of pre-Beatles songs per hour either.
What's the worst problem with locally programmed formats? NOBODY ANNOUNCES THE ARTISTS AND SONGS! I get very upset when I hear a locally-programmed station running on automation where nobody bothered to tag each song with "That's Frank Sinatra with The Way You Look Tonight" or "Haven't Met You Yet by Michael Buble." Ideally the automation system should have one tagged version and one non-tagged version of each song so when there is a live DJ, he can do the announcing. However, AC stations like B101 Philadelphia always played a tagged version and the DJs simply don't announce the songs even when they're on duty. Remember, one of the primary complaints of listeners is "They don't tell me the artists or song titles." So please
TAG YOUR SONGS WITH ARTISTS AND TITLES!
Gregg
[email protected]