A new PD as well might be needed over there....
The thing that I hate above all else on this board is when someone suggests another person should be fired. There’s not a board for people to suggest you should be canned from your Walmart greeter job Robert, but maybe there should be. If you’re going to suggest KRWM needs a new PD, let’s look at some actual data.
Ron Harrell took over KRWM in January 2016, so for a comparison I’m using a neutral pre-Christmas book (October 2015) as a benchmark of where the station was with Carol Handley and looking year-to-year. Demo is Women 25-54, daypart M-F 6a-7p.
October 2015, KRWM was tied for 7th and 46% of their audience was in the 55-64 cell.
Fast forward a year to October 2016, and KRWM is ranked #2, their share increased by 42% and 25-44’s went from making up 14% of their audience to 34% of their audience.
In October 2017, KRWM was up a tenth of a share point from the year before, ranked #3, and they had their highest 25-34 composition probably ever at 20%.
So over the first two years of Ron Harrell as PD, they improved 4 rank positions and had a much more even distribution of age cell composition.
KSWD signed on in December of 2017 and impacted KRWM minimally, but it wasn’t until July of 2018 that the floor fell out under Warm. They went from #4 Women 25-54 in June to #11 in July losing 36% of their AQH. KSWD had been on-air for 7 months at that point and it’s not as if listeners suddenly realized they needed more Hall & Oates in their life and switched from Warm to The Sound. In fact, KRWM shares more W25-54 audience with KQMV, KPLZ, KBKS and KJR-FM than they do with KSWD.
It looks like what happened is 7% of KRWM’s W25-54 panelists left the panel after June – that may not sound like an earth shattering number, but the majority were heavy/deep listeners. To put it in perspective the five previous months 0% of KRWM’s W25-54 panelists left the panel, so 7% in one month is a big hit. It also represented a 62% decline of heavy listeners.
The trend continued in August, September and October and then KRWM saw a slight rebound in November. They’ll likely have a solid December and Holiday, and then we’ll see what 2019 brings.
Overall, the station went from hovering between the 3rd or 4th ranked station consistently every month to dropping out of the top 10 with Women 25-54 in one month’s time. That’s clearly the result of a panel change, not programming decisions.