Agreed. I think old radio nerds like me tend to hate voice-tracked shows because they typically have so little content - because that's what radio programmers want now. "The "DJ" is expected to only open the mic once per music set, and never seems to provide any content either going into or coming out of the stop set.But there is no reason that these shows couldn't have tons of content.
Sure, if the music (or other content) is far removed and interchageable (which ultimately means "disposable"), there is no reason why the DJ can't be either. Just don't expect the DJ to generate the brand identity or the listener loyalty that comes with it. Just by way of comparison, Don Barrett has a story up today about LARPs who could never be imitated or duplicated - one of a kind personalities. Our own Mr. Haggerty came up with a great list that fits the bill:
Art Laboe
Bill Ballance
Bob Crane
Johnny Magnus
The Real Don Steele
Robert W. Morgan
B. Mitchel Reed
Jimmy Rabbitt
Wolfman Jack
Frazier Smith,
Lee Baby Simms
Bobby Ocean
Phil Hendrie
I will add one to his list if I may, the great Jim Healy, who not only performed his own show, but produced all of his own content, and then ran his own board, which is still incredible when you think about it, particularly when you think about the old clumsy carts he had to deal with!
What do all of these guys have in common? They never faxed it in. They never came to the studio for a few hours to "tape the intros" and went on to do a morning TV show. I will stipulate that I believe the Wolfman did tape some of his shows in advance, but you would never know it; he was full energy all of the time and he was certainly not replaceable.