Back in the spring of 1952, when the FCC's Sixth Report and Order that allocated most of the country's television channel assignments for the rest of the analog TV era came out, there were a bunch of Channel 37 assignments. Most of them were small to medium-sized cities ranging in size from Melbourne, Florida to Peoria, Illinois. But one allocation was made to Paterson, New Jersey within the greater New York City area. Had it been applied for and built, it would have gone on the air with a high-power signal, probably from the Empire State building.
Because UHF grew so slowly in the 1950s, only one CP was issued in 1952-53, for station WGOV-TV in Valdosta, GA. Evidently by the end of 1953 no one else had applied for the channel. The CP had evidently been returned by 1957, since WGOV-TV no longer shows up on the list of yet-to=be-built CPs in Broadcasting's 1957 yearbook. The Paterson, NJ allocation didn't last long either---in fact ALL the channel 37 allocations originally enacted in 1952 were gone by 1958. The closest channel to 37 ever used in the New York area was Channel 41, which became home of WXTV (one of the city's principal Spanish language stations) in the 1960s.