Hal Neal was bound by those same constraints when he was at Wixie, and when he moved to WABC (and Fritz took over). Arguably, the constraints were greater in New York with corporate right there watching. But WABC thrived though the 60s and into the 70s; Wixie slid downhill. Yes, AM top 40 was not destined to last forever but top 40 Wixie died before it's time.
Think signal.
(And remember the elephant in the room... CKLW)
The first market Arbitron issued a report for was Detroit. And it was one of the first markets where advertisers in general abandoned Pulse and Hooper in favor of the new survey. While Hooper and Pulse tended to use much smaller survey areas... Arbitron, coming from TV measurement, defined metros consisting of multiple counties that extended often as far as the borders of the next market began. So Detroit suddenly became geographically larger, and the stations with bad signals died.
Keener and Wixie could compete in the smaller market; they played one of the classic Top 40 battle games for a while. At the end of the 60's, Drake's re-do of CKLW ended the game. Evenutally, none of the AMs could not hold up against WDRQ and the FM onslaught.
And WXYZ, due to signal and direct competiton, never had the huge WABC or WLS-like numbers that would make corporate listen to pleas about restricting the net junk.
WABC had coverage of multiple states daytime and listeners in several dozen at night. It did not have a competitor like CKLW with a vastly better signal. It was the 800 lb. gorilla.
WXYZ had miserable local market coverage by daytime, and at night it was even worse. And it had a monster-signal AM competitor.
It's signal, a monster competitor and the redefinition of the metro.
Last edited: